PageForge 1.3: check every run before it writes, update generated pages, spintax and resumable batches. See what changed
Account Get it free

Head-to-head · November 2026

Nav Menu Roles vs Shortcode in Menus

Nav Menu Roles comes out ahead, winning 8 of 8 head-to-head checks against Shortcode in Menus.

Our pick Nav Menu Roles

Nav Menu Roles

This plugin lets you hide custom menu items based on user roles. So if you have a link in the menu that you…

8wins
95
VS
Shortcode in Menus

Shortcode in Menus

Allows you to add shortcodes in WordPress Navigation Menus so that you can generate links dynamically. Also…

0wins
66
MetricNav Menu RolesShortcode in Menus
Active installs 70K+ 50K+
Downloads (30 days) 37.7K 2K
Download trend +722.7% +36%
Rating 4.9/5 4.7/5
Reviews 219 82
Health score 95/100 66/100
Last updated 3 weeks ago 9 months ago
Tested up to WP 7.1.0 WP 6.9.12
Support resolved 100% 100%
Requires PHP 7.4+ 5.6+
First released Sep 2012 Sep 2013

Daily downloads, last 90 days

Nav Menu RolesShortcode in Menus

4K8K12.1KAug 21Oct 4Nov 17

Choose Nav Menu Roles if…

You care most about active installs, downloads (30 days) and download trend.

  • Proven at scale on 70K+ active sites
  • Loved by users — 4.9/5 from 219 reviews
  • Actively developed — last update 3 weeks ago
  • Tested with the latest WordPress (7.1)
  • Momentum — downloads up 722.7% vs the previous 30 days
Full Nav Menu Roles report →

Choose Shortcode in Menus if…

You prefer its feature set and workflow — it holds its own on the fundamentals.

  • Proven at scale on 50K+ active sites
  • Loved by users — 4.7/5 from 82 reviews
  • Momentum — downloads up 36% vs the previous 30 days
  • Only tested up to WordPress 6.9 (latest is 7.1)
Full Shortcode in Menus report →

Both compete in: menus

ShareXLinkedInReddit

FAQ

Nav Menu Roles vs Shortcode in Menus: quick answers

Straight answers, pulled from live WordPress.org data.

Source: WordPress.org

Which is better, Nav Menu Roles or Shortcode in Menus?

Nav Menu Roles comes out ahead, winning 8 of 8 head-to-head checks against Shortcode in Menus. Choose Nav Menu Roles if you care most about active installs, downloads (30 days) and download trend.

Is Nav Menu Roles more popular than Shortcode in Menus?

Nav Menu Roles is the more popular of the two with 70K+ active installs, compared with 50K+ for Shortcode in Menus.

Can I use Nav Menu Roles and Shortcode in Menus together?

Both plugins cover menus, so most sites only need one. Running two plugins that do the same job can cause conflicts and slow your site down — pick the one that fits best and remove the other.

Are Nav Menu Roles and Shortcode in Menus free?

Yes. Both are free to download from the official WordPress.org plugin directory. Either may also offer paid upgrades from its developer.

Powered by PageForge

One template and a spreadsheet. A real page for every search.

PageForge turns each row of a CSV into a WordPress page with its own title, URL, SEO fields and schema, built on the layout you already designed. Free on WordPress.org.

  • CSV and XLSX, plus Google Sheets on Professional and Enterprise
  • Its own title, URL, SEO fields and schema for every page
  • Works with the block editor, Elementor, Divi and Avada
  • Free on WordPress.org, no credit card

↑↓ to move↵ to open